This is topic Constructive criticism please? in forum Old Archives at The Letterville BullBoard.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.letterville.com/ubb/ultimatebb.php/topic/13/2470.html

Posted by Wayne Webb (Member # 1124) on :
 

This design is for a 10'x7' sandblasted HDU entrance sign. It will be mounted on the front of a wall of pylons, rope lashings etc.

What would you do to make it look better? Another shape? Typestyle? Layout? For myself, I'm not particularly elated about the arched upper/lower case John Handy font.
Also, the bottom copy doen't follow the border.

Thanks for the help

------------------
"autograph your work with excellence"

Wayne Webb
Webb Sign Studio
Chipley, FL
850.638.9329
webbsignstudio@digitalexp.com


[This message has been edited by Wayne Webb (edited March 30, 2001).]
 


Posted by old paint (Member # 549) on :
 
wayne...check email...did this 86-87 in sarasota...their not in business any more...might give ya little help

------------------
joe pribish-A SIGN MINT
2811 longleaf Dr.
pensacola, fl 32526
850-944-5060
BEWARE THE TRUTH.....YOU MAY NOT LIKE WHAT YOU FIND


 


Posted by Kevin Landry (Member # 1352) on :
 
Maybe change the white background to a different colour. Say a very light grey to give it that worn look. The font is a bit thin so maybe add a little thickness to it.
But I ain't no arteest either.

Kevin Landry
KnL Signs and Imaging

------------------

 


Posted by Pierre St.Marie (Member # 1462) on :
 
Yep, background color is too stark, and the only other thing I'd say is that the copy looks ok small, but as soon as you blow it up it's going to appear insubstantial. Copy style is ok, just needs a much stronger stroke. my .0000002

------------------
St.Marie Graphics
& Makin' Tracks Sound Studio
Kalispell, Montana
stmariegraphics@centurytel.net http://www.stmariegraphics.com
800 735-8026
We're chiseling every day of the week! :^)



 


Posted by ScooterX (Member # 2023) on :
 
are fiddler crabs yellow? (it looks yellow on my screen). i know they come to the table red, after the boiling water. and i'll vote with changing the background from white to something at least medium colored. otherwise it looks like a highway signs (white and yellow), which might be good at night, but might not make people think "food".

------------------
::scooter::
:: don't blame me... i'm just a beginner

 


Posted by Janette Balogh (Member # 192) on :
 
On the whole I like the shape and the layout concept very much.
Here's what I'd do alittle differently.
Beef up the main title copy just a hair.
Close in the space between the apostrophe and the "s".
Make the Crab bigger, and have the bottom copy weave between his claw.
As for the background colour, I don't mind it white too much. You could tone it to beige or light grey if you want too, but when the crab gets abit bigger, it won't look as stark anymore.


I can't read what the bottom copy says, but unless that's real important info, I'm not sure it's an issue.

I like it Wayne.
Nettie

------------------
"When Love and Skill Work Together ... Expect a Masterpiece"

Janette Balogh
Creative Studio

jbalogh@earthlink.net

 


Posted by Santo (Member # 411) on :
 
I'm not too familiar with fiddler crabs, but I agree it should be bigger and more interesting. We have blue crabs here and I can tell you they are very interesting to examine. Their colors after molting are radiant and they are ballon like. There is a form of a torso of a man formed by the contors on the top of their shells. Take a good look at your subject.

------------------
Santo Brocato
Promotion Graphics & Letters
Youngsville LA.



 


Posted by Wayne Webb (Member # 1124) on :
 
Thanks for all the great help so far.

What do you think if the background was blasted to two depths? The blue could be blasted with a grain fraim and would be blasted deeper than the beige. Also the crab could be hand carved. Nettie, I'm not sure just how to go about passing the small text thru the claw(is that what you meant?). I like the idea though.
What do you think?

------------------
"autograph your work with excellence"

Wayne Webb
Webb Sign Studio
Chipley, FL
850.638.9329
webbsignstudio@digitalexp.com


[This message has been edited by Wayne Webb (edited March 30, 2001).]

[This message has been edited by Wayne Webb (edited March 30, 2001).]
 


Posted by Eric Roche (Member # 1967) on :
 
Hey Wayne
I Sometimes just cant resist putting a spin on things. Take it for what its worth. All of the advice given was excelent as you can see I've incorporated alot of it. Hope this sparks somethin for ya.

------------------
"Someday I'm gonna get a
real job, HEE HEE"
Signs Of Life
48 Carmen Hill Rd.
New Milford, Ct 06776

 


Posted by Wayne Webb (Member # 1124) on :
 
Thanks Eric,
That looks really sharp. What program did you use? What command did you use to make that copy bolder and add the fades? How did you move everything around from a JPG?
Too many questions?

Good job!

------------------
"autograph your work with excellence"

Wayne Webb
Webb Sign Studio
Chipley, FL
850.638.9329
webbsignstudio@digitalexp.com



 


Posted by Eric Roche (Member # 1967) on :
 
Thanks Wayne,
I use corel for this one and in corel
I used the contour tool and added a small
white outline and then a thicker one to give it more weight. I have the font on my system.
so I modified some of the letters so they fit together better. then I redrew the ovals etc. everything but the crab and subcopy
then I took the jpg from your post and made two copies, with the freehand pencil tool I loosely traced around the elements I wanted
on one copy the crab and on the other copy
the sub-copy. I then used the bitmap colormask tool it alows you to block colors in the bitmap, I masked the white and light grey in bitmap basically making the the white in your bitmap transparent once i was happy with that I then Selected the bitmap and Powerclipped it inside the the shape I drew around the elements before. once it was all togehter I played with the colors a little added a bitmap drop shadow to the copy
to give it some depth I also put the crab over the borders to create some depth. Any hoot I had fun doing it if ya ever have any corel questions Drop me an e-mail. If You would like the file I created I'll e-mail it to ya. All you will have to do is rplace the crab & subcopy with your originals.

------------------
"Someday I'm gonna get a
real job, HEE HEE"
Signs Of Life
48 Carmen Hill Rd.
New Milford, Ct 06776

 


Posted by Eric Roche (Member # 1967) on :
 
Shameless bump, Sorry

------------------
"Someday I'm gonna get a
real job, HEE HEE"
Signs Of Life
48 Carmen Hill Rd.
New Milford, Ct 06776

 


Posted by Don Coplen (Member # 127) on :
 
Eric, that layout looks great! Boy, would that ever be ball to carve and blast. You're makin may want to dump my computer graphics gig and get back doin fun stuff.

------------------
Don Coplen aka "SaintPete"
Coplen Designs
St.Petersburg, FL dcoplen@mindspring.com



 


Posted by Wayne Webb (Member # 1124) on :
 

Wow.........that makes me want to get in there and learn that Corel 9 program that I bought over a year ago. So far, all I've done in it is to import and export images and try to make sense of the tutorial that came with it. I bought a set of videos which I plan to use this weekend. I'll try to load my Corel onto this computer tonight. I'm a little slow catching on to things sometimes.

Thanks, Eric, for answering all my questions. I'll be in touch.

------------------
"autograph your work with excellence"

Wayne Webb
Webb Sign Studio
Chipley, FL
850.638.9329
webbsignstudio@digitalexp.com


[This message has been edited by Wayne Webb (edited March 31, 2001).]
 


Posted by Ken Morse (Member # 1799) on :
 
Three very important things about Corel = practice, practice, practice.

------------------
Ken Morse
Jamn Graphics
Santa Cruz, CA
 


Posted by PKing (Member # 337) on :
 
I do like Eric,s version with copy on top of crab.Gives more dimension!Also I think it woild look good if a small part of the crab stuck up outside the oval(just a bump)for even MORE dimension!! Give it that "Out of the box"look
Hope this helps

------------------
PKing is
Pat King of
King Sign Design in
McCalla,Alabama
The Professor of
SIGNOLOGY


 


Posted by Dave Grundy (Member # 103) on :
 
Excellent rework Eric! Nice explanation too! Ain't Corel wunnerful?

It is such an easy program to use. Seriously.

------------------
Dave Grundy
AKA "applicator" on mIRC
"stickin' sticky stuff to valuable vessels and vehicles!"
in Granton, Ontario, Canada
1-519-225-2634
dave.grundy@quadro.net
www.quadro.net/~shirley



 


Posted by Don Coplen (Member # 127) on :
 
Hmmmm.......Trying to start a "controversial thread" here Davey?

I won't bite!

I can handle you on IRC chat!

------------------
Don Coplen aka "SaintPete"
Coplen Designs
St.Petersburg, FL dcoplen@mindspring.com



 


Posted by Eric Roche (Member # 1967) on :
 
Once ya start its hard to stop. Thanks for all the kind comments. Good Idea pat I think it ads alot of dimension and I started foolin with Wayne's idea from the second post. HELP I CANT STOP. I have files on my puter from months and years ago that i find myself opening and tweaking even though the signs are already installed. I thin I might need some Help!

------------------
"Someday I'm gonna get a
real job, HEE HEE"
Signs Of Life
48 Carmen Hill Rd.
New Milford, Ct 06776

 


Posted by Aladd (Member # 1996) on :
 
To me it seems the chosen font is a little tough to read.Is it easier on the eyes when enlarged?

------------------
Alan Ladd
Atlanta,Ga
 


Posted by Wayne Webb (Member # 1124) on :
 
Thanks Eric,
That Main copy looks like it's hovering about 3'' off the sign.....cool! You did that with your Corel? I definitely intend to get in there and learn that. Can't do that with my CAS program.

Alan, that font was chosen by either the customer or the Architectural firm who designed the image at the top of this thread.
I'm not particularly keen on arching upper/lower case copy at all, and especially this one. I think all upper case usually works better. I don't think that this font would work at all in upper case. I have another one called Papyrus which looks really nice but I don't know if they'll go for it yet.

------------------
"autograph your work with excellence"

Wayne Webb
Webb Sign Studio
Chipley, FL
850.638.9329
webbsignstudio@digitalexp.com



 


Posted by Eric Roche (Member # 1967) on :
 
Alright I promise this is it. Thank Janet B. for the background. I just smeared it a little in photopaint. HDU dimensional letters
routed red reveal outline with TC resin on the letters then guilded Mounted on Convex arched backer stud mounted to sign. Sign to be HDU blasted two levels top to emulate sand
maybe footprints or somthin. bottom blasted then sanded smooth and both airbrushed to suite When Blasting Keeping Crab element covered then rout another crab out of HDU carve and airbrush. The crab will actually be behind copy element . I know I'm Just Dreamin But What a BLAST this would be to make and since I still work for somebody else wont be doin anything like that fer a while :{

------------------
"Someday I'm gonna get a
real job, HEE HEE"
Signs Of Life
48 Carmen Hill Rd.
New Milford, Ct 06776

 


Posted by Wayne Webb (Member # 1124) on :
 
Eric, you're pretty good with that CorelDraw!
Brought my VCR/TV and Corel video to the shop this morning. Hopefully, I'll be watching it tonight. For sure I'll get somewhere with it now.

Looks like you could really get into this job. These sure are the fun kind. It's gonna be a monster as far as we're concerned: 10'x7'. Perhaps I should use 2'' Hdu for it. If all goes well, I will post some pics.
Thanks

------------------
"autograph your work with excellence"

Wayne Webb
Webb Sign Studio
Chipley, FL
850.638.9329
webbsignstudio@digitalexp.com



 




Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2